The pre-grip problem vs the grab-and-chew stage
Babies start wanting to chew around two months old, but they can't hold a teether on their own until the pincer grip develops. That's the core difference between a teething mitt and a handheld silicone teether: one straps the teether to the hand, the other expects the baby to hold it.
The Teething Mitt - Elephant is a one-piece molded silicone mitt with a textured teether across the back of the hand. It's built for the pre-grip window, roughly 2 to 6 months, when a loose teether just gets dropped. The mitt keeps the teether on the hand so the baby can bring it to their gums independently.
In contrast, the Teether Single - Ebi Shrimp is a handheld teether sized to fit inside a clenched fist, designed for babies 3 months and up through the full teething stretch. It relies on the baby's developing grip to hold and steer it to the sore spot.
Product facts for the comparison
- Teething Mitt - Elephant: The Teething Mitt - Elephant is a one-piece molded silicone mitt with a textured teether across the back of the hand — built for the pre-grip window, when a baby wants to chew but can't yet hold a teether on their own. This design solves the pre-grip problem: the mitt straps the teether to the hand, so even a two-month-old can self-soothe without dropping it.

Teething Mitt - Elephant - Teether Single - Ebi Shrimp: The Ebi Shrimp teether is a one-handed teether sized to fit inside a clenched fist, easy for a baby to grab and steer to the spot that aches. Once the baby can grasp, a handheld teether gives them more control to find the angle that relieves their gums.

Teether Single - Ebi Shrimp
When to choose the teething mitt
Choose the teething mitt if your baby is in the pre-grip window (roughly 2 to 6 months) and can't yet hold a teether. The mitt straps on and stays put during awake, supervised time. It's also useful if your baby tends to drop or lose handheld teethers before they can retrieve them.
The mitt is for awake, supervised use only — take it off for naps and overnight. The adjustable silicone strap grows with the hand, and cleaning is simple: wipe clean after each session or wash in warm soapy water; top-rack dishwasher safe.
- Best for: Babies 2–6 months who cannot yet grip a teether. Provides relief without the frustration of dropped toys.
- Not for: Sleep or unsupervised use. Once the baby can reliably hold a teether, a handheld version offers more flexibility.
When to choose the handheld silicone teether
Choose the handheld teether once your baby can grasp and hold objects, typically from 3 months onward. The Ebi Shrimp teether is lightweight, easy to grip, and has textured ridges that give the gums a firm surface to press against. Its looped shape stays put even when held upside down.
Some parents chill it in the fridge for a few minutes — many babies prefer the cool silicone on a sore gum. Clean before first use and after each session: wipe with a damp cloth or wash in warm soapy water; top-rack dishwasher safe. Check monthly and replace if you see a crack or tear.
- Best for: Babies 3 months and up who can hold and steer a teether independently. Works through the full teething period.
- Not for: The pre-grip stage before the baby can grasp. A mitt is more effective during that window.
How to decide between them
The choice comes down to your baby's current grip ability. If they're in the pre-grip window (roughly 2 to 6 months) and can't hold a teether, the teething mitt is the practical solution. If they can grasp and hold objects, a handheld silicone teether gives them more control and variety.
Both products are made from food-grade silicone, free of BPA, PVC, phthalates, lead, and cadmium, and are CPSC and CPSIA tested. They also match each other in character design, so you can start with the mitt and transition to the handheld teether as your baby's grip develops.


